
How a golden moment of appreciation turns a stay interview into the conversation that keeps good people.
Years ago, I walked into my manager's boss's office with a resignation letter in my pocket. My direct manager had made work toxic, and I do not have it in my DNA to be disengaged. I was done.
He took one look at my face and said, "I know what you're going to tell me. Please don't tell me now. I invite you to come to my place tonight."
That evening, he offered me an exciting role with full autonomy and responsibilities. I took it, worked harder than ever, and eventually became my former manager’s boss. Except for my former manager, we were all lucky.
Luck is a terrible retention strategy.
42% could have stayed. Almost half were never asked.
Most people never get that evening invitation. Their letter arrives, and everyone acts surprised, even when the writing was on the wall.
- 42% of voluntary leavers said their manager or organization could have prevented their departure (Gallup).
- 45% had no conversation about their satisfaction, performance, or future in their final three months.
- 77% of employees intend to stay, yet 56% stay out of necessity. MetLife calls this job hugging.
- The top three reasons for abruptly quitting were a toxic work environment (32%), poor management or leadership (31%), and feeling disrespected or undervalued (23%). The big surprise? Only 4% cited low pay or lack of benefits as their main reason (Monster).
What could have persuaded them to stay? A healthier workplace culture (63%), more recognition (47%), a different boss (46%), and a raise (46%).
Why are exit interviews ineffective?
People give you the resignation letter but mostly keep the real reasons in their pocket. They want to protect their references and avoid burning bridges. And in Asia, nobody wants to break someone else's "rice bowl."
Stay interviews let you hear what matters while you still have time to respond.
Stay Interview: A well-known antidote
Stay interviews have been around for almost three decades. Beverly Kaye and Sharon Jordan-Evans began this work in 1997, and Richard Finnegan later gave managers a compact set of questions.
But for the interview to succeed, we need goodwill. People forget bonuses. They remember a leader noticing something specific about them and saying it well.
Yet in fast-paced and demanding jobs, many of us save our clearest appreciation for farewell speeches. It is like coming home from a holiday, finding your plant wilted, and watering it then.
The Appreciative Stay Interview Experiment
What if, before we start the interview, we create an environment of human warmth by making the person feel genuinely seen and valued? I call it The Appreciative Stay Interview Experiment.
The inspiration came from my 2016 AI certification with Dr. David Cooperrider at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio. And before you ask, AI here stands for Appreciative Inquiry. The other AI revolution was just starting.

With Dr. David Cooperrider at my Appreciative Inquiry certification ceremony, Case Western Reserve University, 2016.
The appreciative interview is the first part of the Discovery stage in AI. It explores moments when people were at their best, and what gives life to their work.
I've seen people light up when they recall moments when they were at their best. Sometimes, they seem genuinely surprised by how much they've accomplished.
This experiment brings that spirit into the stay conversation.
Seven Steps. Four Happen Before the First Question.
1. Prepare
Preparation starts days before the meeting, in the noticing.
Fernando "Ferns" Yu Jr., president of Jollibee Philippines, keeps a notebook with a page for each of his people. When he notices something great, he shares it on the spot and writes it down.
Before a conversation, he reads the page again and arrives with real examples.
Consider switching on your radar to catch people doing things right, as Ken Blanchard puts it, and writing it down, Ferns-style. When the moment comes, you will say more than “you’re great at, you know, things.”

With Fernando "Ferns" Yu Jr. just before my keynote Delivering Delight for Jollibee Philippines' top 300 franchisees.
Then choose one thing from the past few months that you genuinely value and can back with a concrete example. Look back at what this person told you last time. Which needs remain unmet, which concerns remain unanswered, and which promises remain unkept?
Act on what you can before the meeting, and come ready to explain the rest. Asking someone to open up again, when nothing came of the last time, is a much bigger ask.
2. Share it
Describe what you observed. Be specific about what the person did, and the circumstances that made it meaningful.
Keep it honest. Appreciate only what you sincerely value. People can tell when they are being buttered up, especially when the compliment arrives with a side order of additional responsibilities.
3. Name the impact
Explain how their contribution added value to the business, to the team, or to their own growth.
The Golden Moment: When Someone Feels Seen and Valued
Those first three steps may create a golden moment, a moment when someone feels genuinely seen and valued because someone took the time to notice and to say it well.
The golden moment does not happen every time, and people experience appreciation differently. But when it happens, it can set the table for a more open conversation. Someone should be able to feel appreciated and still tell you that their workload is unreasonable.

The Appreciative Stay Interview Experiment: seven steps, four before the first question. Infographic: Avi Liran.
4. Pause
Give the person time to take in the appreciation. Let the moment breathe, and welcome their response.
If modesty makes them deflect, do not argue. Gently return to the example, and let the facts speak.
5. Bridge
Say, "I'm sure I missed other great things you did," and ask, "What contribution of yours do you wish people understood or appreciated more?" You may hear about the work nobody mentions, which is often the work that matters most to them.
6. Ask
Continue with the stay interview questions selected for the conversation, phrased in language that sounds natural for the manager asking them. Listen carefully, ask follow-up questions, and welcome both positive experiences and difficult truths.
Every manager, employee, and workplace is different, so you choose the questions. Draw on Richard Finnegan's five core questions, the 11 from Beverly Kaye and Sharon Jordan-Evans, a mix of both, or your own questions. Both published sets are in the appendix.
One well-chosen question, asked in your own words, serves the conversation better than a full list read in order. Scripted questions sound hollow. The power of the experiment lies in the sequence: the person feels valued first, and then feels safe to speak candidly.
When they fit the conversation, try these two questions most stay interviews forget to ask:
- Which relationships here at work matter most to you, and what could make them stronger? Researchers call the web that ties a person to a place job embeddedness. In a meta-analysis covering 42,907 people, that web predicted who left, beyond job satisfaction alone. Sometimes, the strongest reason to stay is the people who make coming to work worthwhile.
- Given the resources we have, what could we change, stop, or use differently to help you succeed? Hear the need before you explain the constraints. Sometimes the help is already in the building, just arranged badly.
7. Follow through
Leave with a few things you have agreed to do, and then do them. Explain what you cannot do. Software can remind you of a promise, but no system can keep one for you.
Next time, begin there. Ask what changed and whether it helped. People watch for proof that speaking up made a difference.
The Right Person, the Right Setting, and the Right Vibe
What if the boss is the reason people want to leave?
My manager smoked, shouted, made unreasonable demands, and excluded us from important meetings. He seemed blissfully unaware that he was driving everyone up the wall.
Had he asked me what I thought of his management, I would have told him. But I suspect a stay interview was about as likely as him receiving a nomination for Boss of the Year.
When the manager is part of the problem, give employees the option of speaking with someone else. A senior leader, HR, or someone they trust.
Make it clear what stays confidential. One betrayed confidence can undo a hundred good conversations.
Take Them for Coffee. Leave Your Phone Behind.
Find a comfortable, private spot where you can talk without interruptions, and keep it separate from the performance review. A quiet café can be wonderful.
Switch off your mobile phone. For 45 minutes, give your employee the kind of attention you usually reserve for your phone.
Dear HR, Please Resist the Urge to Create Another Form.
The moment appreciation becomes another box to tick, we've missed the point. Invite a few curious managers to try the experiment, hear what surprised them, and use their feedback to adjust the approach to fit your people and your culture.
Try It Once. See What Happens.
Who is the one person on your team whose resignation would ruin your Monday morning?
Start with them. Try the Appreciative Stay Interview Experiment. You might discover something about them, about yourself, or about your relationship that neither of you expected.
If you try it, tell me what you noticed, what your employee said, and what surprised you. Your stories will show whether this experiment deserves a bigger place in how we keep good people.
One Final Thought:
My manager's boss caught a resignation by reading my face. He was lucky. Your employees might have better poker faces. Extend the invitation while the letter is still only a thought.
Appendix: The Stay Interview Questions
You don't need to use either list in full. Both are included so managers can review them, select the questions that best fit their own leadership style, their relationship with the employee, and the circumstances of the conversation, and set the rest aside. A combination of the two sets, or questions drawn from elsewhere, is equally valid.

Richard Finnegan’s books on stay interviews, retention and engagement.
Richard Finnegan offers five core questions, each with its own follow-up probes.
- What do you look forward to each day when you commute to work?
- What are you learning here, and what do you want to learn?
- Why do you stay here?
- When is the last time you thought about leaving us, and what prompted it?
- What can I do to make your job better for you?

Love ’Em or Lose ’Em, sixth edition, by Beverly Kaye and Sharon Jordan-Evans.
Beverly Kaye and Sharon Jordan-Evans, in the sixth edition of Love 'Em or Lose 'Em, offer a menu of 11 questions.
- What one change in your current role would make you consider staying in this job?
- If you had a magic wand, what would be the one thing you would change about this department, team, organization?
- As your manager, what could I do a little more of or a little less of?
- If you had to go back to a position in your past and stay for an extended period of time, which one would it be and why?
- What do you need to learn to work at your best?
- What makes for a great day?
- What can we do to make your job more satisfying?
- What can we do to support your career goals?
- Do you get enough recognition? How do you like to be recognized?
- What do you want to learn this year?
- In what ways do you feel valued and included by the team?
Sources
- Tatel, C. & Wigert, B. (2024, updated 2026). 42% of Employee Turnover Is Preventable but Often Ignored. Gallup.
- MetLife (2026). Job Hugging Is Undermining Workplace Outcomes: 2026 Employee Benefit Trends Study.
- Monster (2025). Revenge Quitting Poll, as reported by Staffing Industry Analysts.
- Kaye, B. & Jordan-Evans, S. Hello Stay Interviews, Goodbye Talent Loss, preface (1997 origin).
- Kaye, B. & Jordan-Evans, S. Love ’Em or Lose ’Em, sixth edition, top 11 questions, as listed by Bob Tiede and in the publisher’s sixth edition sample.
- Blanchard (2025). Catch People Doing Things Right by Martha C. Lawrence Celebrates the Power of Positive Leadership.
- Finnegan, R. How to Conduct Stay Interviews: 5 Key Questions. SHRM.
- Jiang, K., Liu, D., McKay, P., Lee, T. & Mitchell, T. (2012). When and how is job embeddedness predictive of turnover? A meta-analytic investigation. Journal of Applied Psychology